By its very nature, the investing industry is full of differing views on how one ought to invest their hard-earned cash. One of the more polarising debates is whether an investment in gold makes good sense. The debate tends to flare up each time gold experiences a rapid growth in value, such as in the last couple of years.
The pros
Gold has long been prized for its lustre and durability in jewellery, but its uses extend beyond this. As an excellent conductor, highly malleable, stable at high temperatures, and resistant to rust, gold is invaluable in industries like electronics, medicine, and aerospace. Its enduring demand contributes to its value and appeal to investors, as gold has retained purchasing power across centuries. For instance, in gold terms, the pay of a Roman centurion 2,000 years ago is comparable to that of a modern U.S. army captain.
Other positives are that gold offers uncorrelated returns to traditional assets such as bonds and equities, providing potential diversification benefits. Many see gold as an ‘Armageddon hedge’, expecting strong returns when faith in the financial system is shaken. Unlike many investment opportunities, gold is a relatively simple concept – being a lump of metal with a market value – and is easily accessed via physical purchase or low-cost open-end funds.
The cons
Gold prices are a function of supply and demand. Investors in gold speculate that others will desire it even more avidly in the future. Unlike traditional asset classes, gold produces no income stream, it does not pay dividends and usually costs owners to store and insure it. Many assume its long term expected return to sit somewhere near cash.
The chart below shows the increase in value of 1 ounce of gold from 1926 to August 2024, rising from around $20 to just over $2,500. Investing the same $20 in global equities during this period would have delivered a substantially superior outcome, nearly 50 times the cumulative gain.
Investors seeking an Armageddon hedge face a dilemma: while many opt for gold-backed funds or ETFs due to the challenges of storing physical gold, relying on the financial system to hedge against its collapse seems contradictory. Owning physical gold has its own issues due to its bulk and other risks such as theft.
Though gold is often promoted as an inflation hedge, the evidence is weak. While it has maintained value over millennia, its performance over more relevant timeframes is less impressive—gold has yet to recover its February 1980 inflation-adjusted high in USD terms and saw an 83% drop in value over the following two decades.
The portfolio
Assessing whether gold belongs in your investment portfolio is the job of our investment committee. Each asset class must fill a specific role in your portfolio and is weighed up against the alternatives. In the case of gold, whilst it has some favourable characteristics, superior options exist.
As Warren Buffet succinctly puts it:
If you own one ounce of gold for eternity, you will still only own one ounce at its end.'
